About  |   Contact  |  Mongabay on Facebook  |  Mongabay on Twitter  |  Subscribe
Rainforests | Tropical fish | Environmental news | For kids | Madagascar | Photos | Non-English languages | Tropical Conservation Science| Store

Comments: Temperate forests store more carbon than tropical forests, finds study



We offer two comment systems: our "Add a comment" system (no registration) and a social media system (registration with Disqus required). Either one will allow you to post a comment here.

Mongabay comment system

Add a comment:

Name (required)

Email (required but private)


an interesting article but it would be nice to know what time scale these figures are worked at. Presumably they are annual figures but I think a mention of this would have been very useful.

Steve Fowles

These aren't annual figures. They represent the cumulative sequestration of carbon over hundreds or even thousands of years.

Tim.o.Thy

First a correction, the cited E regnans forest 2844tC/ha is actually CO2et/ha.

The av. annual seq. rate is only 8 tCO2/ha/an(2844tCO2/ha div. by 350 yrs)

Natural forests characteristically have low sequestration rates. Sadly they are inefficient for the urgent task of removing C02 from the atmosphere.

Old growth Rainforest sequestration rates:
Tasmanian 350yr E Regnans, 8 tCO2/ha/an
Amazon 350yr tropical 4 tC02/ha/an
NZ Kauri 1500yr 2 tC02/ha/an
Pacific NW D-fir 3 tC02/ha/an

Managed planted forest seq.rates can range from 40-80 tCO2/ha/an
Highest seq. rates occur in tropical hardwood plantations and require use of fertilisers.

There are two urgent tasks for global forestry, to protect existing forest carbon sinks (which take centuries to accumulate), and to utilise the rapid growth potential of managed forests to suck C02 from the atmosphere.

mark belton

Mark Belton: The study says "C/ha" not "CO2/ha".

Annual sequestration rates aren't particularly relevant when you are talking about a situation where old-growth forest is replaced with plantation forest since the plantation forest will not store as much carbon as the old growth forest.

Rhett (author)

Social media comment system

blog comments powered by Disqus


Please note
  • Inappropriate and "frivolous" (i.e. First!) comments may not be posted and spam will not be tolerated. "Trolling" attempts will be deleted.
  • Comments are approved manually at the discretion of the mongabay.com administrator. Mongabay.com tries to approve comments on a timely basis, but in some cases, comments may take a few days to be approved.
  • The comment system is not a way to communicate directly with the author of the article or the site administrator. Please contact the author for requests and corrections.
  • Links (urls) are not active in posted comments.

Back to news.mongabay.com/2009/0717-forest_carbon.html

All comments

News index





Copyright mongabay 2010